Ice Cream & Cookie Cakes
Personally Made in our Shop
From personal treats to party-size centerpieces, our ice cream & cookie cakes are a crowd-pleasing favorite.
Ice Cream Cakes
Why everyone loves them
Each cake is built for texture, flavor, and a clean finish that looks as good as it tastes.
Layered texture
Cookie or crust base, creamy filling, and decorative topping.
Celebration friendly
Available in personal, family, party, and premium tall cakes.
Custom-ready
Add premium layers, decorations, and a message for special occasions.
Cookie Cakes
Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Each cake made to order from our 'famous' sourdough chocolate chip cookie recipes and can be decorated for your occasion.
9" Round Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake $22
Celebration friendly +$3
We can add personalized decorations for a small fee.
Add a Dozen Cookie to complete the box ($15 - $36)
Why not add some extra cookies, you can select just one type or mix and match.
Cake Menu
Choose the size and style that matches your celebration, from simple and sweet to fully customized.
$7.95
5x5 Personal Cake
Serves 2
Multiple layers including a crust, 2 different ice creams, and a decorative whipped topping.
Pre-order Highly Recommended
$29.00
8x8 Family Cake
Serves 6–8
Great for small gatherings and family birthdays. Multiple layers Including crust, 2 ice creams, and whipped topping. Designs and letter can be added for an additional fee.
Pre-order Required
$45.00
9x12 Party Cake
Serves 10–12
Our party-size layered cake with a crust, 2 different ice cream flavors, and a decorative whipped topping. Chocolate lettering can be added for an additional $10
Pre-order Required
$49.00
Classic Tall 9" Round
Our tall 9 inch round ice cream cake, built in a springform pan
Extra height & smooth sides
Cookie crust base
One layer of ice cream with a crumble layer between the second layer of ice cream (you can choose the same flavor or a different flavor)
Whipped topping finish
Simple border or sprinkle top
Pre-order Required
$59.00
Premium Layered Tall 9"
Extra richness
Includes everything in the Classic, plus one premium interior layer for added crunch or richness.
Pre-order Required
$69.00
Customized 9" Tall
Our most indulgent
Our tallest, Premium version with multiple premium layers, custom decorations, and/or a personalized message on top.
Pre-order Required
Details & Ordering Notes
Helpful information for customers before they place an order.
Pre-order guidance
For family, party, and custom cakes, pre-ordering helps ensure availability and gives time for decoration requests.
Customization ideas
Add a personalized message, sprinkles, themed toppings, or premium crunch layers to make your cake event-ready.
Ready to order your cake?
Use this form to get started, or call us directly at 727-475-7002.
Cakes must be paid for at least 48 hours in advance of pickup.
Come Visit & Follow Us
